[Deathpenalty] death penaty news----TEXAS, PENN., FLA., OHIO, TENN.
Rick Halperin
rhalperi at smu.edu
Thu Sep 13 10:02:44 CDT 2018
September 13
TEXAS----new execution date
Execution date set for East Texas man who beat, killed 13-month-old during
'exorcism'
An execution date is set for a Rusk County man accused of the beating death of
a 13-month-child.
Blaine Milam, 28, was sentenced to death in 2010 for the death of 13-month-old
Amora Carson during an alleged exorcism.
According to the Texas Department of Criminal Justice, the execution date for
Blaine Keith Milam, 28, is set for Jan. 15, 2019.
Amora died in December 2008 after she was fatally struck by Milam to rid her of
demons. She was also bitten multiple times and beaten with a hammer.
(source: KTRE news)
********************
Executions under Greg Abbott, Jan. 21, 2015-present----35
Executions in Texas: Dec. 7, 1982----present-----553
Abbott#--------scheduled execution date-----name------------Tx. #
36---------Sept. 26---------------Troy Clark--------------554
37---------Sept. 27---------------Daniel Acker------------555
38---------Oct. 10----------------Juan Segundo------------556
39---------Oct. 24----------------Kwame Rockwell----------557
40---------Nov. 7-----------------Emanuel Kemp, Jr.--------558
41---------Dec. 4-----------------Joseph Garcia-----------559
42---------Jan. 15----------------Blaine Milam------------560
43---------Jan. 30----------------Robert Jennings---------561
(sources: TDCJ & Rick Halperin)
******************----impending execution
Execution delay sought for man convicted of hijacking bus, raping and killing
passenger
The lawyer for a Tarrant County man set to be executed in November for
hijacking a city bus, then raping and killing a passenger in Fort Worth in 1987
is seeking a delay in the execution as he fights for DNA testing to be done in
the case.
In a motion filed Friday, attorney Greg Westfall argues that DNA testing has
never been done in the capital murder case that sent his client, Emanuel Kemp
Jr., to death row.
He argued the case against Kemp was largely circumstantial and relied heavily
on the testimony of a single witness - bus driver David Jeanfreau.
Westfall also filed a separate motion asking the court to withdraw Kemp's
execution date - set for Nov. 7 - until the DNA motion and related issues "may
be fully litigated."
County criminal court Magistrate Charles Reynolds issued an order Monday,
giving the District Attorney's office 60 days to file a response to Westfall's
motion.
Westfall declined to comment to the Star-Telegram, adding "the motion kind of
speaks for itself."
Samantha Jordan, a spokeswoman with the Tarrant County District Attorney's
office, said she could not comment on the motion Wednesday.
Reached by phone Wednesday, Jeanfreau said he remains sure of Kemp's guilt in
the rape and fatal stabbing of Johnnie Mae Gray, a 34-year-old emergency room
clerk at John Peter Smith Hospital who was a regular on his bus.
"I never had any doubt that this is the right guy," said Jeanfreau, who now
resides in Colorado.
The crime
Kemp, who had a past history of aggravated robbery, had been released from
prison days earlier when, officials say, he boarded a city bus late on May 27,
1987.
David Jeanfreau, the bus driver, testified he was approaching the stop for
Gray, a regular passenger, when he heard Gray say something about her purse and
turned to see Kemp standing over his shoulder with a knife.
"This is a robbery," he testified Kemp told him.
Jeanfreau said he initially cooperated with Kemp because he believed it would
save him and Gray, his lone passenger. He said he followed Kemp's order and
drove to a secluded parking lot inside Trinity Park.
There, he testified, Kemp raped Gray on a bus seat, then began stabbing her.
Jeanfreau testified that when he yelled at Kemp to "Just get out. You got what
you wanted. Why don't you just leave?'," Kemp turned the knife on him, stabbing
him in the neck. Jeanfreau told jurors he was able to escape out the back door
of the bus, jumped into the river, and then hailed down a passing motorist.
Police arrived in the early morning hours of May 28, 1987, to find Gray dead
aboard the bus from multiple stab wounds.
4 days after the attack, Jeanfreau picked Kemp out of a police lineup as the
person responsible, telling jurors he was "absolutely sure" he had picked the
right man.
Kemp's defense attorney at the time, Leon Haley, argued that police never fully
investigated other potential suspects in the case, including the bus driver.
The argument
In his motion, Westfall points out that Kemp never confessed to the crime and
that another rider on the bus, who'd been dropped off before the hijacking,
failed to identify Kemp in a police lineup.
"This was, for the most part, a circumstantial case," Westfall states in the
motion. "The bus driver was the only person to make an identification at the
lineup, which was a cross-racial identification. He was the only identity
witness to testify."
Westfall also argues that the only physical evidence in the case was a shirt
found along with the dead woman's purse in the Botanic Gardens.
Other evidence included testimony that Kemp was seen getting out of a yellow
Lincoln Continental before boarding the bus - the same kind of car owned by
Kemp's mother, the motion states.
If DNA testing is conducted on biological evidence in the case - including a
sexual assault evidence collection kit, a bus seat cover with a semen stain,
and blood collected from the crime scene and a shirt - Westfall argues his
client could be excluded as the source, undermining such circumstantial
evidence.
His motion includes transcripts of testimony from two people who testified in
Kemp's trial - Fort Worth crime scene officer Jim Varnon and Billie Shumway, a
forensic serologist with the Fort Worth police crime lab.
Varnon testified that out of 14 identifiable latent fingerprints he collected
from inside the bus, none belonged to Kemp.
Shumway testified that neither Kemp nor the bus driver could be excluded as the
source of the semen stain found on the bus seat or the semen found in Gray's
sexual assault kit. She testified the 2 men were among about 32 % of the males
in Tarrant County who could have been the source based on their blood type.
"The results of her testing were imprecise to say the least, and included both
(Kemp) and the bus driver in the population of persons who could have been
responsible for the biological specimens found on the bus," Westfall states in
his motion. "The total population who could have been responsible equated to
about 1/3 of the males in Tarrant County."
A jury convicted Kemp in April 1988 and sentenced him to death.
"Punishment fits the crime"
Gray's mother died in 2004, online record searches show.
Jeanfreau said he's occasionally checked through the years to see if an
execution date had been set for Kemp. But he said he has no plans to be there
to see Kemp put to death by lethal injection, nor is he overly concerned about
a possible delay in his date with death. After all, he said, it's already been
31 years.
"I'm not really emotionally riveted by what happens to this guy," Jeanfreau
said. "Clearly I think the public has supported his existence long enough with
state funds, but I'm not obsessed with the execution date."
Still, Jeanfreau said, he believes "the punishment fits the crime."
"I have no objection to the death penalty when it's appropriate," he said.
Kemp has been on death row since 1988 and has had at least 1 prior execution
date set. He was a week away from lethal injection when a federal judge
intervened in 1999 and granted him a stay until the he could be appointed a new
attorney.
His attorneys (Westfall has represented him since 1999) have previously argued
that Kemp has schizophrenia and is too severely mentally ill to be executed.
Kemp, 52, was brought from death row and booked into the Tarrant County Jail on
Aug. 29 on a bench warrant while his fate is determined.
He remained held there Wednesday.
(source: star-telegram.com)
PENNSYLVANIA:
Scott Wagner says he'll restore death penalty, sue pharmaceutical companies in
opioid fight
Republican candidate for Governor, Scott Wagner, spoke about his ideas on
fixing the opioid epidemic for the 1st time on Wednesday, at the Country Club
of York.
Republican Scott Wagner wouldn't wait until he was sworn in as governor to
fight Pennsylvania's opioid epidemic.
The day after winning the election, he would start inviting stakeholders to an
opioid summit he'd plan for Tuesday, Nov. 27. The crisis is too dire to wait
for a swearing-in ceremony in January, Wagner said.
About 5,500 Pennsylvanians died from drug overdoses in 2017, according to the
most recent numbers available from the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and
Prevention. That's an 8 % increase from the previous year.
Gov. Tom Wolf and Attorney General Josh Shapiro aren't doing enough to fight
the problem of opioid addiction in Pennsylvania, Wagner said.
Wagner accused Wolf of taking campaign money from pharmaceutical lobbyists and
not holding drug makers accountable.
Wolf and Shapiro have spent time and money filing lawsuits against President
Donald Trump, but they haven't sued pharmaceutical companies that flooded the
state with addictive painkillers, Wagner said.
Shapiro and attorneys general in 40 other states last year launched an
investigation into companies that make prescription painkillers and
distributors that deliver them.
Wagner slammed that coordinated effort.
"Being in a coalition is like being the member of a card club," he said.
(source: York Daily Record)
FLORIDA----new death sentence
Man sentenced to death after killing cellmate
Daniel Craven, Jr. will be the 1st man sentenced to death in the 14th Judicial
Circuit since Florida's new death penalty law passed in 2017.
Craven was found guilty in June by a Jackson County jury of killing his
cellmate, John Anderson. The murder happened while the 2 were housed at the
Graceville Correctional Facility in June 2015.
Craven stabbed Anderson to death with a shank.
When the jury found Craven guilty in June, they unanimously recommended the
death verdict. Wednesday a judge agreed and sentenced him to death.
(source: WJHG news)
************************
Jackson County Judge Sentences Man to Death
Wednesday, 14th Circuit Judge, Christopher Patterson, sentenced Daniel Craven
Jr. to death, following the unanimous recommendation by the 12 person jury in
the trial.
In June, Craven was found guilty of 1st degree murder, for stabbing his
Graceville Correctional Facility cell mate, John Anderson, to death. He was
already serving a life sentence from a 2011 murder in south Florida.
When the verdict was read, Craven was seen smiling.
Craven is the 1st person in the 14th circuit to receive the death penalty since
the Supreme Court made changes to the capital sentencing law.
Those changes require that each juror votes and agrees on the death sentence,
before the judge can impose such a sentencing.
(source: mypanhandle.com)
***********************
Judge grants killer's request to remain on death row
Jonathan Huey Lawrence's request that he remain on Florida's death row was
granted Wednesday by Santa Rosa Circuit Court Judge David Rimmer.
Lawrence, a Santa Rosa County man who within 40 days in 1998 participated in
the brutal murders of 2 people and tried to kill a third, originally was
sentenced to die Aug. 16, 2000.
Rimmer upheld the death sentence Lawrence had received for killing Jennifer
Robinson and mutilating her body. A rehearing of the penalty phase of his trial
was required by court order because the jury that had convicted him recommended
he die by an 11-1 vote.
The Florida Supreme Court has declared jurors must decide unanimously to impose
the death penalty, and state law was changed in 2017 to reflect that decision.
Sentences imposed decades ago across the state, like Lawrence's, are being
reconsidered.
Lawrence was charged alongside Martel Rodgers with killing the 18-year-old
Robinson on May 7, 1998. Court documents state the men drove Robinson to a
secluded place, served her alcohol until she was intoxicated, had sex with her
and killed her.
The men used a knife to remove Robinson's calf muscle, which they kept, and
also took photographs of her body. Evidence, including the body part and
photos, were located along with documentation that clearly indicated the murder
had been planned.
After his arrest Lawrence also confessed to helping Rodgers kill Justin
Livingston, Lawrence's cousin, on April 9, 1998. After Rodgers had stabbed and
attempted to strangle Livingston, Lawrence finished him with several knife
blows to the back.
Lawrence also pleaded to shooting through a house window in an effort to kill
Layton Smitherman, who Lawrence didn't even know. He and Rodgers "had been
driving around that evening looking to get into trouble, preferably to find
somebody to shoot and kill," the court record said.
After 17 years on death row and with a re-sentencing hearing looming, Lawrence
sent a handwritten note to Rimmer.
"I'm guilty of all my charges and deserve my death sentence. I've had no
intention of putting the families, friends and loved ones of the people I
deliberately help(ed) murder through all of these 20 long years of grief,
suffering and loss to have to (e)ndure more," the note said.
Lawrence waived his right to have a jury hear the re-sentencing proceeding and
to have mitigating factors heard in his defense, a news release from the State
Attorney's Office said. The court had appointed a special counsel to provide
mitigation evidence.
The new penalty phase began June 4 and mitigating factors were heard Aug. 20,
the release said.
(source: nwfdaiynews.com)
OHIO:
High court issues stay on Hundley execution
The Ohio Supreme Court ordered a stay on the execution of Lance Hundley while
his appeal remains pending.
Judge Maureen A. Sweeney of Mahoning County Common Pleas Court sentenced
Hundley to death after a jury convicted him in the November 2015 beating and
strangulation death of Erika Huff.
Hundley, 48, of Warren, was set to be executed Nov. 6.
In addition to the aggravated-murder charge that resulted from Huff's killing,
the jury convicted Hundley of the attempted murder of Huff's mother, and
aggravated arson for trying to burn his victims and Huff's Cleveland Street
home.
Huff was confined to a wheelchair, and her mother arrived at the home after
Huff's medical alarm went off.
Hundley's case qualified for the death penalty because he tried to kill 2
people in the same course of conduct.
All defendants sentenced to death in Ohio have an automatic right to appeal
their case to the high court. Hundley filed a notice of appeal in June shortly
after Judge Sweeney imposed the death penalty.
(source: The Youngstown Vindicator)
*************
Execution stalled for man convicted in Youngstown beating death, arson
The man convicted of a 2015 Youngstown beating death and arson case will not
face the death penalty this fall- after the Ohio Supreme Court has agreed that
he should receive a stay of execution.
The Supreme Court issued a ruling Wednesday granting a motion to give
48-year-old Lance Hundley more time.
Hundley, who appealed his death penalty conviction in June, is scheduled to be
executed on November 6th. However, the ruling from the Ohio Supreme Court
orders that no execution date can be scheduled while appeals proceedings are
underway.
Hundley was sentenced to the death penalty in June, following several years of
criminal proceedings.
Hundley was found guilty on several charges, including aggravated murder,
attempted murder, felonious assault, and aggravated arson in the death of
41-year-old Erika Huff in 2015.
In June, Mahoning County Judge Maureen Sweeney sentenced Hundley to death for
Erika Huff's murder and an additional 22 years in prison. 11 years for the
attempted murder of Huff's mother Denise Johnson, and eleven more years for
setting the home on fire.
Prosecutors say Hundley attacked Huff at her home on Cleveland Street, beat her
to death, and then set the home on fire to cover up the crime.
Officials say when Hundley encountered Huff's mother, Denise Johnson outside
the home, he attacked her with a claw hammer.
Officers responding to calls for help removed an air conditioner from the back
of the home and rescued Johnson.
After that rescue, they found Huff's body. Huff was confined to a wheelchair,
unable to walk because she suffered from MS.
Police originally said Hundley was living in the home and was inside when
police arrived. Hundley was arrested and was also taken to St. Elizabeth Health
Center for injuries.
Erika had a 6-year-old daughter who was not in the home at the time of the
fire.
An online court docket does not yet have a date set for when the Ohio Supreme
Court may hear arguments on the appeal.
(source: WFMJ news)
TENNESSEE:
Edmund Zagorski's Case Illustrates 'Tennessee's Death Penalty Lottery'----The
state is set to execute Zagorski on Oct. 11 for 2 drug-related killings in 1983
Tennessee plans to execute Edmund Zagorski on Oct. 11 using the same lethal
injection drugs that, according to medical experts, tortured Billy Ray Irick
last month. The state's death penalty apparatus is up and running after being
dormant for nearly a decade, and Zagorski's will be the 2nd of 3 executions
scheduled in Tennessee this year.
A 63-year-old man who's been on death row for 34 years, Zagorski was convicted
in 1984 for the murders of 2 Dickson County men, John Dale Dotson and Jimmy
Porter. Authorities said the 2 men had planned to buy marijuana from Zagorski
but that Zagorski shot them, slit their throats and robbed them. His case, like
so many capital cases, includes a host of complicating factors, from his
treatment after his arrest to the arguably arbitrary nature of his sentence.
Ahead of his trial, Zagorski reportedly told his lawyers that if he was
convicted he preferred the death penalty, and confessed to the crimes. He would
later challenge the admissibility of his statements, arguing that police had
coerced him into confessing. A court filing from earlier this year lays out the
argument that his confession and other damaging statements he made after his
arrest - including waiving his right to counsel after first saying he didn't
want to be questioned without a lawyer present - were involuntary and made
under extreme duress in the Robertson County jail.
"Those statements were the product of inhumane conditions and unconstitutional
coercion," the filing reads, "because Zagorski was placed in solitary
confinement in an unventilated metal hotbox for seven (7) weeks during the heat
of the summer, which decimated him physically and mentally, made him mentally
ill and suicidal, and led him to give statements in order to end the unbearable
conditions."
The filing goes on to detail how Zagorski's mental health deteriorated as he
was held in solitary confinement. He was put on an antipsychotic medication
and, on one occasion, "was brought to the emergency room with 'acute anxiety,'
he was 'sweating [and] anxious' and in an 'uncontrollable rage,' having beaten
his knuckles bloody against the metal wall."
Zagorski's attorneys argue in the filing that no Tennessee court has fully
considered the evidence and issues around his pretrial statements. They even
raise doubts about Zagorski's guilt.
But further, Zagorski's case is a perfect example of a phenomenon highlighted
in a report published earlier this year in the Tennessee Journal of Law and
Policy. The Intercept's Liliana Segura wrote about some of the report's
findings last month following Irick's execution. Titled "Tennessee's Death
Penalty Lottery" and authored by attorneys Bradley MacLean and H.E. Miller Jr.,
the 97-page document casts Tennessee's death penalty as a "cruel lottery" that
metes out the ultimate punishment on an arbitrary basis.
As part of the research for the report, Miller conducted a survey of
Tennessee's 1st-degree murder cases. Among his findings, as cited in the filing
in Zagorski's case: "Over the past 40 years, Tennessee has convicted more than
2,500 defendants of 1st degree murder. Among those 2,500+ defendants, only 86
defendants (3.4%) received sustained death sentences, and only 6 defendants (or
1 out of 400) were executed."
In the filing, Zagorski's attorneys argue at length that his death sentence in
particular is arbitrary and, thus, unjust when compared with the sentences
other Tennesseans have received for crimes that are similar or worse. To begin
with, they argue that prosecutors in Zagorski's case acknowledged that death
was not required for justice - they offered Zagorski 2 life sentences in
exchange for a guilty plea, but pursued the death penalty when Zagorski
insisted on going to trial. Moreover, they detail how other drug-related
homicides have been handled by the state's justice system.
According to the filing: "At least 20 (twenty) other persons convicted of
drug-related double homicides (or worse) have not been sentenced to death, but
to life imprisonment," and "while triple and double drug-related homicides in
Tennessee have resulted in life sentences, there is a long list of persons who
have committed triple, quadruple, quintuple, and even sextuple homicides in
Tennessee for whom the punishment imposed has been only life imprisonment."
Zagorski's attorneys go on to cite specific cases, such as that of Henry
Burrell and Zakkawanda Moss, who are serving life sentences for the murder of 6
people.
Now, after more than 3 decades on death row, Zagorski's execution date is less
than 30 days away. He's been scheduled to die before, but this time - in light
of the fact that Tennessee executed an inmate a month ago - his chances of
being strapped to a gurney and wheeled into the execution chamber seem higher.
Gov. Bill Haslam's office confirms to the Scene that they have received
Zagorski's application for clemency and that the governor and his legal staff
are reviewing the request. Zagorski's Memphis-based clemency attorney, Robert
Hutton, tells the Scene that out of respect for the governor he's not
discussing the specifics of the case for now.
Hutton does say, though, that Zagorski is an extraordinarily rehabilitated man
who hasn't been written up once for behavior issues in his 34 years in prison.
He also notes a problematic detail about Zagorski's sentence: When Zagorski was
tried in the early '80s, the jury did not have the option of sentencing him to
life without parole. Today, every state with the death penalty gives juries
that option.
Meanwhile, the legal fight over Tennessee's controversial new lethal injection
protocol continues. A Nashville judge upheld the protocol ahead of Irick's
execution, but the dozens of death row inmates challenging are appealing that
decision. The Tennessee Supreme Court is set to hear oral arguments in the case
on Oct. 3, just 8 days before the state plans to use the drugs again.
(source: Nashville Scene)
More information about the DeathPenalty
mailing list