[Deathpenalty] death penalty news----TEXAS, FLA., GA., KY., OKLA., COLO.

[Rick Halperin]

May 13




TEXAS----stay of impending execution

Fort Worth death row inmate gets second stay of execution this year


An appeals court has postponed a 2nd execution date for a death row inmate from 
Fort Worth who was scheduled to die next week.

In an order issued Friday, the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals ruled that they 
would review Tilon Lashon Carter's application for relief before going forward 
with his execution, which was scheduled for Tuesday.

Carter, 37, was convicted of the robbery and 2004 slaying of James Tomlin, 89, 
a Bell Helicopter retiree. Prosecutors said that Carter and his girlfriend, 
Leketha Allen, went to Tomlin's home to rob him and took $6,000. Allen was 
sentenced to 25 years after agreeing to a plea bargain arrangement with 
prosecutors.

Carter's attorney, Raoul D. Schonemann, filed a motion on Tuesday to set aside 
the execution date, arguing that new evidence conflicts with evidence that was 
presented at trial. The motion also states that Carter had ineffective trial 
counsel and was denied due process because Nizam Peerwani, Tarrant County 
medical examiner, presented false and misleading testimony.

Peerwani's testimony led the jury to believe that Tomlin had been intentionally 
smothered, even though Tomlin's cause of death was listed as "smothering with 
positional asphyxia," which may not have been intentional, the motion contends. 
Carter's trial attorney never sought evidence highlighting the role that intent 
played in the trial, which Schonemann used to bolster his allegation that 
Carter had ineffective counsel.

The motion also argues that the autopsy results, from Peerwani and 3 other 
experts, do not support the theory that Tomlin's death was caused by an 
intentional act.

Carter survived an earlier execution date scheduled for Feb. 7 due to a 
technicality. The appeals court granted a stay of execution by a 5-4 vote on 
the grounds that notice of the scheduled execution date arrived 1/2 a day late 
at a state office that sometimes works on death penalty appeals.

2 death row inmates from Tarrant County have been executed this year. 
Christopher Wilkins was put to death on Jan. 11 for a double murder committed 
in Fort Worth. He was the 1st person to be executed in the United States this 
year.

Texas also executed a former Kennedale auto mechanic who killed a father and 
his infant son in a 1987 Christmas Eve killing spree. James Eugene Bigby, 61, 
was pronounced dead on March 14.

An execution date for Paul Storey, which had also been set for this year, was 
stayed pending a hearing.

Storey, 32, who was convicted for the murder of Jonas Cherry, was scheduled to 
die on April 12. Cherry, a manager at the Putt-Putt Golf and Games in Hurst, 
was shot twice in the head and twice in his legs on Oct. 16, 2006 on a robbery.

(source: star-telegram.com)

****************************

Juan Castillo's execution date has been changed from May 24 to September 7.

Executions under Greg Abbott, Jan. 21, 2015-present----24

Executions in Texas: Dec. 7, 1982----present-----543

Abbott#--------scheduled execution date-----name------------Tx. #

25---------June 28------------------Steven Long-----------543

26---------July 19-----------------Kosoul Chanthakoummane---544

37---------July 27-----------------Taichin Preyor---------545

28---------Sept.7------------------Juan Castillo----------546

(sources: TDCJ & Rick Halperin)

****************************

Former Mavs ManiAAC dancer receives life sentence after jury deadlocks


A former Mavs ManiAAC dancer received life in prison after the jury in his 
murder trial deadlocked on the death penalty.

Erbie Bowser killed 4 people and wounded 4 children during a 2013 shooting 
rampage. He was on trial for 1 of the murders.

The jury got hung up on the death penalty and deadlocked. The judge had to go 
with a life sentence in prison without the chance of parole.

The jury had already signaled it was having trouble with a verdict on the 
punishment after being sequestered overnight. They began sending out a note on 
Friday for a clarification on "beyond a reasonable doubt".

Bowser was found guilty of capital murder for the death of 4 women and wounding 
several children.

Prosecutors said in 2013 Bowser went to his girlfriend's house and killed Toya 
Smith and her 17-year-old daughter and then went to DeSoto to kill his 
estranged wife, Zina Bowser, and her 28-year-old daughter.

Smith's mother, Lurlean, had some words for Bowser at the end of the trial.

"You not only killed once, you killed 4 times," she said. "And you left four 
innocent children without parents. But those children are going to go on with 
their lives and will have a good life."

Defense attorneys tried to show Bowser was not guilty by reason of insanity 
because of his military service and concussions from playing football had 
impacted his mental state.

(source: Fox News)






FLORIDA----female to face death penalty

Kimberly Lucas to stand trial in September in toddler's drowning death


A September trial date has been set in the death penalty case of Kimberly 
Lucas, the Jupiter woman charged with drowning the 2-year-old daughter she 
shared with her former partner and trying to kill their 10-year-old son.

Circuit Judge Charles Burton set Sept. 14 as the date for prospective jurors to 
come in and begin filling out jury questionaires in the case surrounding the 
2-year-old Elliana Lucas-Jamason's May 2014 drowning death and the drugging of 
then 10-year-old Ethan Lucas-Jamason. Burton's move comes weeks after Florida's 
4th District Court of Appeal lifted a stay of the proceedings because of issues 
surrounding Florida's death penalty.

Jacquelyn Jamason, the children's mother and Lucas' former partner, said after 
the hearing she was glad that the case was finally going to trial.

According to court records, Lucas had tried to drug both Ethan and Elliana with 
the anti-anxiety drug Alprazolam, telling her son the pill "would help make him 
grow." Ethan took the pill, but when Elliana was unable to swallow it, Lucas 
drowned her in a bathtub.

Lucas' attorneys plan to pursue an insanity defense, arguing that Lucas suffers 
from dissociative identity disorder, formerly known as multiple personality 
disorder, and that one of her alters committed the crimes.

(source: Palm Beach Post)

**********************

Florida Supreme Court sets aside death sentence for mass-murderer Nelson 
Serrano


The Florida Supreme Court, in a 4-3 decision released Thursday, set aside the 
four death sentences against Serrano, 78, and sent the case back to Circuit 
Court for resentencing.

Nelson Serrano, who was sentenced to death in 2007 for the execution-style 
killings of 4 people at a Bartow manufacturing plant, is getting a new 
sentencing hearing.

The Florida Supreme Court, in a 4-3 decision released Thursday, set aside the 4 
death sentences against Serrano, 78, and sent the case back to Circuit Court 
for resentencing.

The ruling doesn't overturn Serrano's convictions for the murders, nor does it 
mean he will be released from prison. At resentencing, the jury will decide 
between life imprisonment and the death penalty in a case that remains the 
worst mass murder in Polk County history.

State Attorney Brian Haas said Friday his office will seek the death penalty 
against Serrano.

"We ... have already begun to prepare for the retrial of the penalty phase," he 
said.

He said it would be at least several months before the case goes before a 
12-member jury.

A Polk County jury convicted Serrano in October 2006 for killing his former 
business partner and another former partner's son, daughter and son-in-law at 
Erie Manufacturing in Bartow in December 1997.

Prosecutors said Serrano, who had been ousted from Erie, traveled to Atlanta on 
business, then secretly flew back to Florida, committed the murders and 
returned to Atlanta using aliases to make airline and car rental reservations.

Investigators broke Serrano's alibi in 2001 when they discovered his 
fingerprint on a parking garage receipt at the Orlando International Airport 
the day of the killings.

By the time a Polk County grand jury issued a sealed indictment in 2001, 
Serrano had returned to his native Ecuador, which refused to extradite him 
because of Florida's death penalty.

In September 2002, agents with the Florida Department of Law Enforcement worked 
with Ecuadorian agents to deport Serrano, who had claimed American citizenship.

Circuit Judge Susan Roberts sentenced him to death for each of the 4 murders in 
June 2007.

In March 2011, the Florida Supreme Court upheld the conviction and death 
sentence against Serrano on initial appeal.

Thursday's ruling by the state's high court came on a subsequent appeal.

The court based its decision Thursday on a January 2016 ruling affecting most 
Florida murder cases involving imposition of the death penalty after June 2002.

The 2016 ruling, called Hurst vs. Florida, rendered the state's death penalty 
process unconstitutional, forcing the Legislature to revise it. That revision, 
which became law earlier this year, mandates that jurors must agree unanimously 
in their decision to recommend the death penalty. Before that, state law 
required only a simple majority.

Meanwhile, in 2002, a U.S. Supreme Court decision in an Arizona case required 
that juries, not judges, decide whether prosecutors have proven the facts 
supporting a death sentence. That clashed with Florida's system, which gave 
judges that authority, but Florida elected not to change its death penalty 
process.

The Hurst ruling forced that change, and the Florida Supreme Court has ruled 
that the revised law applies to condemned inmates who were sentenced after 2002 
without a unanimous jury recommendation.

At Serrano's trial, jurors voted 9-3 to recommend that the judge sentence him 
to death for each of the 4 killings.

Marcia Silvers, a Miami lawyer representing Serrano, said she thinks the high 
court made the correct decision.

"We are grateful that the Florida Supreme Court overturned the death penalty, 
acknowledging that a unanimous verdict is the cornerstone of our justice 
system," she said.

In Thursday's ruling, the 3 dissenting justices said they didn't agree that 
Serrano's death sentences should be vacated.

And George Patisso, whose son George Jr., was among those who died, said he was 
devastated when he learned of the resentencing.

"We have to go through this all over again," he said Friday from his home in 
New York. "I really don't want to, but for my son, I will because I want to see 
this to the end. (Serrano) ruined so many people's lives."

Patisso said he and his wife, Mary Ann, hope Serrano will remain on death row.

"We want him to suffer because he has made us suffer for the last 20 years," he 
said. "He has devastated us. It just doesn't go away."

His wife, Mary Ann, said she doesn't want him to be able to interact with other 
inmates.

"I want him to sit alone," she said.

George Patisso Jr. was 27 when he was working at Erie Manufacturing, where his 
father-in-law, Phil Dosso, was a partner. He worked with his brother-in-law, 
35-year-old Frank Dosso, and George Gonsalvez, 69, another partner in the 
business.

All 3 were gunned down in an office about 6 p.m. Dec. 3, 1997, each shot in the 
head.

Diane Dosso Patisso, a 28-year-old prosecutor with the State Attorney's Office 
in Bartow, had arrived at Erie to pick her husband when she was shot in another 
office. Prosecutors said it appeared she had walked in on the shootings and was 
killed because she had witnessed the crime.

Tommy Ray, a retired FDLE agent who broke Serrano's alibi and orchestrated his 
deportation, said Friday he's concerned for the families involved.

"The Dossos are devastated," he said. "The real travesty is for the families 
that have to go through this all over again."

Francisco Serrano, who has stood by his father throughout the trial and 
appeals, couldn't be located for comment Friday.

(source: The Ledger)

***************************

Killer could be granted new trial


A Bay County man condemned to death in 1981 for kidnapping and brutally 
murdering a woman he knew could get another chance to argue for his innocence, 
according to court records.

That chance, however, will depend on the outcome of an upcoming forensic DNA 
test.

James Armando Card, 70, has been on death row since 1982, when he was convicted 
of the robbery, kidnapping and first-degree murder of Janice Franklin. A recent 
Florida Supreme Court ruling opened the possibility for Card to receive a 
second shot at a penalty phase. His defense attorneys further argued Thursday 
that DNA evidence collected after the conviction also could position Card to 
have the case tried more than 3 decades later in front of another Bay County 
jury.

The status of the case has been tentative since a U.S. Supreme Court decision 
last year upended Florida's death penalty procedures. More recently, the 
Florida Supreme Court ruled May 4 the jury decision to sentence Card to death 
by a margin of 11-1 was insufficient and deserving of a 2nd penalty hearing.

"This court has no way of knowing if the jury unanimously found each 
aggravating factor, whether the aggravating factors were sufficient to impose a 
death sentence, or whether the aggravating factors outweighed the mitigating 
circumstances," the Florida Supreme Court wrote of the decision. "Further, this 
court cannot speculate why the 1 juror who voted to recommend a sentence of 
life imprisonment determined that a sentence of death was not the appropriate 
punishment."

The court then sent the case back to the 14th Judicial Circuit, where Card's 
case once again is being argued. The direction of those arguments will be 
steered in the coming weeks by the outcome of a DNA test, which defense 
attorneys think could benefit Card while prosecutors disagree.

Circuit Judge Michael Overstreet has ordered Card to submit a sample for 
testing within 2 weeks. That sample will be sent to the Florida Department of 
Law Enforcement for analysis, and depending on the outcome Card could move for 
a new trial.

(source: Panama City News Herald)






GEORGIA----impending execution

Execution drug will cause unconstitutional pain, lawsuit says


Georgia's lethal injection drug carries a substantial risk of causing 
unconstitutional suffering for an inmate scheduled to die Tuesday, and 
execution by firing squad is the only appropriate alternative, his lawyers 
argue.

J.W. Ledford Jr. was convicted of murder in the January 1992 stabbing death of 
his neighbor, 73-year-old Dr. Harry Johnston, near his home in Murray County, 
in northwest Georgia.

Ledford, 45, suffers from chronic nerve pain that has been treated with 
increasing doses of the drug gabapentin for more than a decade, his lawyers 
said in a federal lawsuit filed Thursday. They cite experts who say long-term 
exposure to gabapentin alters brain chemistry in such a way that pentobarbital 
cannot be relied upon to make him unconscious and devoid of sensation or 
feeling.

"Accordingly, there is a substantial risk that Mr. Ledford will be aware and in 
agony as the pentobarbital attacks his respiratory system, depriving his brain, 
heart, and lungs of oxygen as he drowns in his own saliva," the lawsuit says.

That would violate the prohibition on cruel and unusual punishment enshrined in 
the Eighth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution, Ledford's lawyers argue. But the 
U.S. Supreme Court has said that when challenging an execution method on those 
grounds, an inmate must propose a "known and available" method of execution.

Ledford's lawyers, therefore, suggest that he be executed by firing squad.

There is no alternative method of lethal injection available to the state since 
the drugs used in executions have become increasingly difficult for states to 
obtain because manufacturers have prohibited their use for capital punishment, 
the lawsuit says. But the Supreme Court has held that execution by firing squad 
is constitutional, and Georgia already has the skilled personnel, weapons and 
ammunition needed to carry one out, Ledford's lawyers argue.

There are numerous law enforcement officers who currently have the necessary 
training to pass a proficiency test to qualify for a firing squad, they say.

They note, however, that the 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals has previously 
ruled -- including as recently as this week in an Alabama case -- that an 
inmate can only suggest an alternative execution method that is already 
authorized by Georgia law, and Georgia law only allows execution by lethal 
injection.

3 states -- Mississippi, Oklahoma and Utah -- allow for a firing squad as a 
backup if lethal injection drugs aren't available, said Robert Dunham, 
executive director of the Death Penalty Information Center, which compiles 
statistics on capital punishment.

Ledford is effectively prevented from meeting the burden imposed by the Supreme 
Court of proposing an alternative execution method when challenging the state's 
execution protocol as unconstitutionally cruel and unusual since state law only 
allows for lethal injection, his lawyers say.

For that reason, they say they recognize that a dismissal of their lawsuit on 
those grounds is inevitable and say that a quick dismissal would allow enough 
time for them to request a hearing before the full 11th Circuit.

The office of state Attorney General Chris Carr had no comment Friday morning 
on the lawsuit, spokeswoman Katelyn McCreary said in an email.

U.S. District Judge Steve Jones has ordered the state's lawyers to file a 
response to the lawsuit by 4:30 p.m. Friday.

Ledford's lawyers also have asked the judge to order the state not to 
discontinue or withhold his medication pending his execution. That could cause 
him to suffer withdrawal symptoms and would leave him to experience the pain 
for which the gabapentin was prescribed, they say.

Ledford is scheduled for execution at 7 p.m. on May 16.

Ledford's attorneys also have asked the State Board of Pardons and Paroles to 
spare his life, citing a rough childhood, substance abuse from an early age and 
his intellectual disability.

The board, which is the only authority in Georgia with power to commute a death 
sentence, plans to hold a meeting Monday to hear arguments for or against 
granting clemency.

68 men and women have executed in Georgia since the U.S. Supreme Court 
reinstated the death penalty in 1976. 57 men currently face death sentences in 
the state. Ledford is expected to be the 47th inmate put to death by lethal 
injection, WGCL-TV reports.

(source: CBS news)

**************

Condemned murderer: I want to die by firing squad ---- Argues lethal injection 
could cause him "agony"


Condemned murder J.W. "Boy" Ledford Jr. has asked a federal court to declare 
lethal injection unconstitutional because Georgia law does not allow him to 
choose death by firing squad.

In a federal complaint, Ledford's lawyers wrote that he has been taking 
medication for "severe and chronic nerve pain" for years and the drug, 
gabapentin, had changed his pain chemistry.

"There is a substantial risk that Mr. Ledford will be aware and in agony as the 
(lethal injection drug) pentobarbital attacks his respiratory system, depriving 
his brain, heart and lungs of oxygen as he drowns in his own saliva," according 
to the complaint.

Ledford is set to be executed next week for murdering his neighbor, a 
73-year-old doctor, in northwest Georgia 25 years ago. If he dies by lethal 
injection as planned, Ledford will be the first person Georgia has put to death 
this year.

But his lawyers want lethal injection be declared unconstitutional because 
Georgia law does not allow condemned murderers to chose the method of their 
executions. They write that there could be a "horrific" reaction to the 
pentobarbital, and that would violate Ledford???s constitutional protection 
from cruel and unusual punishment, the federal complaint says.

His lawyers raise the issue of death by firing squad just a few days after the 
11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals denied an Alabama death row inmate's request 
the he be allowed to choose hanging or firing squad.

"Mr. Ledford proposes that the firing squad is a readily-implemented and more 
reliable alternative method of execution that would eliminate the risks posed 
to him by lethal injection," the complaint says. "The binding precedent of the 
11th Circuit, however, restricts Mr. Ledford to proposing only those 
alternatives already authorized by Georgia statute."

"As the Georgia code allows no method of execution but lethal injection, and 
given the broad unavailability of alternative drugs, Mr. Ledford is effectively 
foreclosed from meeting his burden in this action," it continiues. "Mr. 
Ledford's dilemma illustrates why this standard is unworkable."

The filing late Thursday is Ledford's 1st attempt, using the courts, to stop 
his scheduled execution since the U.S. Supreme Court refused to step in early 
last month.

The complaint was filed in federal court in Atlanta as the State Board of 
Pardons and Paroles was releasing Ledford's clemency petition. In it, his 
lawyers wrote that he is deeply sorry for murdering Dr. Harry Johnston in 
Murray County.

The clemency petition also says five of the jurors who voted for the death 
penalty would now like to see him serve life without parole instead.

"The inflexibility of the legal system sometimes leaves an otherwise deserving 
individual without a remedy," his lawyers wrote. "Inevitably there will be 
instances in which the fixed rules governing the legal process yield a result 
that does not accommodate fairness. Clemency exists for just this situation."

But District Attorney Bert Poston, who prosecutes in the circuit that includes 
Murray County where the crime was committed, said if ever a murder called for 
the death penalty, the 1992 murder of Dr. Harry Johnston did.

"I've seen the pictures," said Poston, who became a prosecutor in the circuit 
only 2 months before Johnston's murder. "I've been doing this for 25 years and 
I've handled a lot of murder cases and I can't think of many that come close."

The State Board of Pardons and Paroles will hear from Ledford's advocates 
Monday morning and then in the afternoon from Poston and others who want to see 
the sentenced carried out.

Ledford, 45, is scheduled to be executed Tuesday at the Georgia Diagnostic and 
Classification Prison near Jackson, one of two men who are set to die by lethal 
injection in the country on that day; Texas also has an execution scheduled. 
Last year, Georgia executed nine men, more than any other state.

Johnston's widow died in February, Poston said.

"She wanted very much to live long enough to see justice served," Poston said. 
"All the delays have robbed her of that."

According to court records, one of the cuts that Ledford delivered to Johnson's 
neck almost decapitated the 73-year-old man, who had been the doctor who 
delivered Ledford, whom his lawyers repeatedly referred to using his nickname, 
"Boy Ledford."

Ledford admitted to the murder but claimed it was in self-defense. He said the 
doctor had struck him during an argument over whether the younger man had 
stolen from his neighbor.

"Boy Ledford confessed to killing Dr. Johnston the day after he was arrested 
and has never denied killing him," the clemency petition said. "The pain of 
killing the doctor is something that he lives with daily."

Ledford's lawyers say he was drunk and using drugs on the day of the crime. 
According to testimony and court records, Ledford had consumed a 6-pack of 
16-ounce beers, smoked about 10 marijuana cigarettes and had taken some pills. 
Ledford told one doctor who examined him that he "was generally 'messed up.'"

His lawyers wrote in the clemency petition that Ledford, whom identified by his 
nickname "Boy," started drinking when he was 8 and moved on to drugs by age 10. 
His father was a "mean drunk" and a strict disciplinarian who abused Ledford 
and his 6 sisters, usually when he was using drugs or drinking, the clemency 
petition said.

"The background is not an excuse for what Boy Ledford has done," the lawyers 
wrote. "It is offered to allow the board some insight into how a young man 
barely 20 years old with no history of violence ended up killing a man who was 
his neighbor."

(source: Atlanta Journal Constitution)






KENTUCKY:

Death-penalty trials keep getting delayed. A Lexington judge is fed up.


Chief Fayette Circuit Judge Pamela Goodwine said she plans to more closely 
monitor the progress of death-penalty cases after experiencing difficulties in 
advancing 1 capital case toward trial.

Her desire for more progress comes after it became apparent last month that a 
death-penalty trial scheduled to start May 30 will be postponed.

Goodwine became upset April 27 after public defenders Kim Green and Chris Tracy 
sought to delay a murder trial for Quincinio Canada and Duwan Mulazim.

The 2 men are charged with murder, robbery and assault in the 2014 shooting 
death of Marine Lance Cpl. Jonathan Price, 26, and the wounding of his wife, 
Megan. The 2 were celebrating Megan's birthday when they were shot in the 
parking lot of Austin City Saloon in Lexington.

Green, Mulazim's attorney, and Tracy, Canada's attorney, said they could not be 
ready by May 30 because of the complexity of issues involved in preparing for 
trial.

Goodwine initially resisted delaying the trial but relented May 4 when it 
became evident that to push forward risked a possible appeal and retrial. 
Tempers flared and tears were shed over the course of a couple of hearings 
before Goodwine decided that more time was needed.

Under the Constitution, a criminal defendant has a right to the effective 
assistance of legal counsel at trial. Tracy and Green argued that they could 
not provide that effective counsel.

"There's not a remote chance that we are even close to being ready," Tracy told 
Goodwine on April 27. "There are so many issues of such complexity that are 
still left to litigate in this matter."

Goodwine said she intended to start the trial as scheduled. "The only way this 
is going to stop is to hold feet to the fire," she said, her voice rising.

The judge added: "I've tried 10 capital cases in 13 years and every single one 
of them has had a motion to continue 30 days before trial because they need 
more time."

But on May 4, when the defense indicated that it needed time to sort through 
Canada's juvenile court records for mental-health evidence, Goodwine said she 
would postpone the trial to a later date.

Assistant Commonwealth's Attorney Kimberly Baird acknowledged that to push 
forward risked a "reversible error" on appeal.

But Baird added, her voice cracking and dabbing at tears: "That is so unfair to 
the commonwealth. I recognize this is me being angry, is what this is. ...It's 
so not fair. I recognize this is going to get continued, as does the victim's 
family. I recognize it's probably going to be next year" before jury selection 
begins.

Debbie Price, Jonathan Price's mother, was also frustrated. Jonathan's birthday 
was May 4, the day of the hearing when it became apparent that the trial 
regarding his death would not begin as scheduled.

"We're disappointed in all these last-minute motions," Debbie Price said after 
the hearing. But she added, "We don't want the defense to come back and say 
something was done wrong. We want everything done right the 1st time."

Fayette isn't the only county where frustration is mounting over repeated 
delays. Last month Madison Circuit Judge William Clouse Jr. rescheduled a 
capital case of 2 defendants charged in the 2015 shooting death of Richmond 
police officer Daniel Ellis. Clouse had previously said he would not grant a 
continuance.

On May 3, the mother of Logan James Dean Tipton could be heard asking why the 
public defenders have filed a motion for a continuance in the case of the man 
charged with stabbing the 6-year-old Versailles boy to death. (Kim Green, a 
public defender in the Canada-Mulazim case, is also defending Exantus.)

Ed Monahan of the state's Department of Public Advocacy said delays are a 
consequence of heavy workloads faced by public defenders. The duty to 
investigate, prepare and try the guilt/innocence and sentencing phases of a 
capital case requires an average of 1,900 hours, according to the American Bar 
Association.

In the Canada-Mulazim matter, public defender Green has 6 capital cases. The 
bar association recommends that a public defender should have no more than 3.

"Each judge wants, very understandably, to move their docket," Monahan said. 
"One of the consequences with having a public defender program that doesn't 
have enough resources to do the work adequately is we have to ask for 
continuances, because we don't have the capacity to do the cases on a time 
schedule that judges, witnesses, clients and victims deserve. We're in these 
difficult situations because we have to get enough time to represent the client 
and we ask for a lot of continuances."

As part of her new protocol, Goodwine said she intends to hold status hearings 
every 30 days to make sure that the defense and prosecution are moving forward 
and meeting deadlines.

She also wants to create a master calendar so that there aren't scheduling 
conflicts between judges. One problem in the Canada-Mulazim case was that their 
public defenders had another capital case scheduled to start the month before 
in Judge James Ishmael's court. Green and Tracy said there was no way they 
could adequately prepare for both.

The trial before Ishmael was eventually rescheduled for next year. Goodwine 
doesn't want that kind of scheduling conflict to happen again.

"If I have this schedule in place with deadlines, and if there is a pattern of 
failing to comply with a deadline, it gives me the ability to say 'You're not 
getting it continued any more,' or I can fine" the lawyers, Goodwine said.

"Ideally, the defense attorneys and the commonwealth's attorneys, 30 to 45 days 
out from the start of trial, should be doing nothing but preparing for trial."

In the meantime, 3 capital cases are scheduled for trial later this year in 
Fayette Circuit Court.

Travis Bredhold goes on trial Sept. 5 in the 2013 shooting death and robbery of 
Mukeshbhai Patel, 51, at a Marathon station on Alexandria Drive.

Efrain Diaz and Justin Smith are scheduled for trial Oct. 2 in the 2015 
shooting death and robbery of University of Kentucky student Jonathan Krueger, 
22.

Robert Guernsey and Trustin Jones are scheduled for trial Nov. 1 in the 2013 
shooting death and robbery of Bluegrass Community and Technical College student 
Derek Pelphrey, 23.

Goodwine has not set a new date for the Canada-Mulazim trial.

(source: kentucky.com)






OKLAHOMA:

Delay death penalty


I understand the frustrations of anti-death penalty people. I also understand 
the "fry 'em" mentality of pro-death penalty people. I was once one of those.

There are people who definitely deserve the death penalty but we do not deserve 
to hand out that punishment if we cannot guarantee that no innocent people are 
executed. People should not form an opinion on this matter until they research 
and understand what they are making a serious decision about.

The problem is we trust our system, we trust our detectives, we trust our 
prosecutors and we trust our jurors so much that when a guilty verdict is 
handed down with capital punishment as the sentence we say, "Good, he deserves 
it." But we shouldn't trust all those people or the system blindly like that. 
We are supposed to question things and make sure our government is working.

The Death Penalty Review Commission report states that there are numerous 
problems with our system and executions should be put on hold until the 
problems are fixed. Yet executions continue. Why did they even have a Death 
Penalty Review Commission in the first place? It was a waste of 18 months.

The death penalty needs to be put on hold at the very least until the state can 
guarantee the citizens of this state that we are not executing innocent people. 
And if that cannot be guaranteed then the death penalty should be abolished.

Jennifer Hale, Pryor

(source: Letter to the Editor, Tulsa World)






COLORADO:

Judge denies Chuck E. Cheese killer's 2nd plea for legal funding----Nathan 
Dunlap's lawyers want $750,000 to help convince Hickenlooper he deserves 
clemency


Federal Senior Judge John Kane has rejected a second plea by lawyers for Chuck 
E. Cheese killer Nathan Dunlap seeking $750,000 to help persuade Gov. John 
Hickenlooper to commute his death sentence.

In an order posted Thursday, Kane wrote that it would be irresponsible "for me 
to authorize the expenditure of such a large sum at this point" for the purpose 
of attempting to persuade the governor to grant Dunlap clemency. He added that 
Hickenlooper previously stated that an earlier decision to grant Dunlap a 
reprieve was "related to the death penalty itself, not circumstances specific 
to Mr. Dunlap."

The lawyers want the money to develop new evidence from a psychiatrist about 
Dunlap's traumatic childhood on his decisionmaking. They hope the evidence will 
persuade Hickenlooper to commute their client's sentence.

Kane noted that the funds were sought through the federal Criminal Justice Act, 
which limits the amount that can be spent on expert, investigative and other 
expenses to $7,500. But Dunlap's request included a petition for $215,000 in 
expert and investigative expenses, which is 28 times the statutory limit, he 
wrote.

"In addition to not establishing that the services are reasonably necessary, 
Mr. Dunlap also has not sufficiently shown that the services are of such an 
unusual character or duration that they merit trampling the statutory limit," 
Kane's denial released Thursday says.

Dunlap was 19 in 1993 when he went to the Chuck E. Cheese's where he once 
worked and killed Ben Grant, 17, Sylvia Crowell, 19, Colleen O'Connor, 17, and 
50-year-old Margaret Kohlberg, all employees who were closing the restaurant 
for the night. He also severely wounded another person.

Dunlap was sentenced to death in 1996, and he was scheduled for execution in 
August 2013. On May 22, 2013, Hickenlooper announced he had given him a 
temporary, but indefinite, reprieve to life in prison.

Kane's order also takes aim at Hickenlooper's reprieve, noting that a reprieve 
is "a temporary postponement of an execution of a criminal sentence, especially 
a death sentence" for an interval of time.

"Such an indefinite reprieve strains credulity," Kane's order says. "It is 
absurd to suggest that - temporary can be contorted to mean - 'indefinite'."

Dunlap's attorneys previously said members of Hickenlooper's staff have 
suggested the attorney's strategy may be received favorably, but not until the 
end of his term in early 2019.

Hickenlooper's spokeswoman Jacque Montgomery previously denied that the 
governor has given any indication one way or the other. But Hickenlooper has 
said is considering a possible commutation of the death sentence.

(source: Canon City Daily)