[Deathpenalty] death penalty news----IA., KAN., MO., OKLA.
Rick Halperin
rhalperi at smu.edu
Tue Aug 18 09:51:12 CDT 2015
Aug. 18
IOWA:
Peter Neufeld of The Innocence Project to Deliver 35th Bucksbaum Lecture
The co-founder of an organization that seeks to exonerate wrongly convicted
inmates through DNA testing will deliver the 35th installment of the Martin
Bucksbaum Distinguished Lecture Series at Drake University.
Peter Neufeld, co-founder of The Innocence Project, will deliver the free
public lecture at 7 p.m. Tuesday, October 27, in the Drake University Knapp
Center. Seating is general admission and tickets are not required.
The Innocence Project is a national non-profit organization that represents
hundreds of inmates seeking post-conviction release through DNA testing and
pursues institutional reform to identify and address the systemic causes of
wrongful convictions.
More than 300 people have been exonerated by DNA testing in the United States,
including 18 people who served time on death row. The Innocence Project's
full-time staff attorneys provided direct representation or critical assistance
in almost all of those cases, with the assistance of students at the Benjamin
N. Cardozo School of Law at Yeshiva University. The wrongly convicted
individuals served an average of 14 years in prison before exoneration and
release.
"The increasing public attention to the issues of mandatory sentences and the
nation's level of incarcerations make this an important time to hear more about
the work of the Innocence Project," said Neil Hamilton, professor at Drake Law
School. "The number of individuals the Project's lawyers have helped free from
prison makes the group a key player in efforts to improve the justice system in
the United States."
The Innocence Project advocates for more rigorous scientific validation of
forensic procedures and other techniques routinely used by law enforcement
outlets and prosecutors in criminal justice cases. Among the first 325
DNA-based exonerations in the United States, eyewitness misidentification was a
contributing factor to wrongful convictions in 72 % of cases. Unverifiable or
improper forensics were a contributing factor in 47 % of cases; false
confessions in 27 % of cases, and the use of informants in 15 % of cases.
"For years, despite lacking a proper scientific foundation, many forensic
practitioners have offered either unvalidated evidence or grossly exaggerated
the value of the evidence, particularly in forensic disciplines that examined
pattern, impression, and trace evidence, e.g. comparison of bite marks, shoe
prints, bullets, and hair," Neufeld wrote in a March 30 op-ed to The New York
Times. Other contributing factors include government misconduct and bad
lawyering, according to the Project.
In addition to working to free wrongly convicted inmates, the Innocence Project
also includes a policy department that works to pass laws and implement
policies that prevent wrongful conviction; a strategic litigation department
that works to improve case law through targeted legal work; and a social work
department that supports exonerees as they rebuild their lives post-release.
Neufeld is a partner in the New York civil rights law firm of Neufeld Scheck &
Brustin, LLP, where he focuses on constitutional law and police misconduct.
When not acting as primary counsel, Neufeld has provided pro bono services to
dozens of lawyers representing the accused in death penalty cases. He has
lectured and taught students, lawyers, judges, legislators, and scientists on
subjects at the intersection of science and criminal justice. Before
co-founding the Innocence Project, Neufeld taught trial advocacy at Fordham
University Law School.
(source: Drake University news)
KANSAS:
Jury selection begins for white supremacist's murder trial
An avowed white supremacist who admitted he killed 3 people outside 2 Jewish
sites seemed upbeat as jury section began in his capital murder trial. Officers
wheeled Glenn Miller into a Johnson County courtroom on Monday; he was wearing
a jacket and tie and his hair was neatly combed.
Miller, 74, lives near Marionville, Mo. He has chronic emphysema and has been
using a wheelchair and oxygen during courtroom proceedings since his arrest in
April 2014.
Miller admits he gunned down a woman, man and teenager outside 2 Jewish centers
in Overland Park. He said he was targeting Jews, although none of the 3 victims
were Jewish.
Miller represents himself in the trial, which likely will last several weeks.
He could get the death penalty if he's convicted of capital murder. A judge
ordered his lawyers to be present to continue the trial in case he decides to
remove Miller from the courtroom for misbehavior or impermissible statements.
The judge refuses to let Miller use the defense that his intent to kill Jews
was for the greater good of society because Jewish people have taken over
important societal institutions.
Miller offered to plead guilty in return for not getting a death penalty if
he's allowed to make a statement about why he committed the murders. The
Johnson County district attorney refused to accept the guilty pleas, but won't
say why because of the judge's gag order on attorneys in the case.
(source: ky3.com)
MISSOURI:
Judge sets trial date for Craig Wood for murder of Hailey Owens
A man charged with kidnapping, raping, and killing a 10-year-old girl is now
set for trial in September and October of next year. A judge on Monday
scheduled Craig Wood's trial to begin on Sept. 26, 2016, possibly to last until
Oct. 21.
Wood is charged with grabbing Hailey Owens off a street near her home in
western Springfield on Feb. 18, 2014, throwing her in his pickup, raping her,
fatally shooting her in the head, and putting her body in a plastic tub in his
home's basement in central Springfield. Prosecutors want a death penalty if
they get a first-degree murder conviction.
Defense attorneys wanted plenty of time to prepare for trial, because of other
pending death penalty cases. They asked for the trial to be scheduled in March
2017. Prosecutors told a judge that they could be ready in March 2016. Greene
County Circuit Judge Tom Mountjoy on Monday split the difference; he didn't go
with the prosecutors' date to try to ensure Wood's right to effective counsel
is not violated. It's possible the date could change.
Defense attorneys, prosecutors and the judge agreed months ago that Wood's jury
will come from Platte County, on the north side of the Kansas City metro area
near Kansas City International Airport, because of extensive publicity about
Hailey's murder. The trial will be in Springfield with a sequestered jury.
Wood was a coach and aide at Pleasant View Elementary and Middle School, north
of Springfield, at the time of Hailey's murder. He worked for the Springfield
School District for 16 years. Investigators have not said, if they know, why
they think Wood kidnapped a girl from another school and area of the city where
he neither lived nor worked. Hailey attended Westport Elementary School.
(source: ky3.com)
OKLAHOMA:
When in doubt, decline use of death penalty
As the controversy involving convicted killer Richard Eugene Glossip plays out
in Oklahoma, it is receiving a fair amount of attention in Glossip's native
state, Illinois.
Ironically, Glossip wouldn't face the same fate if he had been convicted of
murder in Illinois, and as doubt lingers about Glossip's guilt as his execution
date nears, it indicates why Illinois is on the right side of the capital
punishment question.
Glossip, 51, was born and raised in Galesburg, and in an interview published
last weekend, he told his hometown newspaper, The Register-Mail, Oklahoma is
going to "kill an innocent man'' if they carry his execution out.
He was convicted in 1998 of killing Barry Alan Van Treese, owner of a Best
Budget Inn in Oklahoma City. Prosecutors said Glossip feared being fired and
devised a plot to kill Van Treese. The motel's maintenance man, Justin Sneed,
pleaded guilty to killing Van Treese. He admitted to bludgeoning him to death
in a hotel room and testified against Glossip in exchange for a sentence of
life without parole.
Despite vigorous objections from Van Treese's family, Glossip has maintained
his innocence and has drawn some prominent people to his side.
Sister Helen Prejean, Glossip's spiritual advisor and author of "Dead Man
Walking," a book which examines moral issues related to the death penalty, has
repeatedly defended the death row inmate. Susan Sarandon, who played Prejean in
the movie adaption of "Dead Man Walking," also has rallied to his defense.
When Van Treese was murdered in 1997, forensic science was not nearly advanced
as it is today, and Glossip was convicted largely on circumstantial evidence
and the testimony of Sneed.
Doubt of Glossip's guilt has remained ever since, and O'Ryan Justine Sneed,
Sneed's daughter, has written a letter asking for clemency for Glossip. She
said her father has expressed his desire to recant his testimony, and the
letter included this paragraph:
"I am sure that Mr. Glossip did not do what my father originally said, that he
did not hire my father to kill Mr. Van Treese, and he doesn't deserve to die
over my father's actions. One innocent life has already been taken by my
father's actions. A second one doesn't deserve to be taken as well."
The letter was written long after Glossip was originally convicted, had that
conviction overturned, and was convicted anew in 2004. Thus, it is not
considered evidence. But it does cast only further doubt on Glossip's guilt,
and just a glimmer of doubt is all it should take to call off the execution.
That's what former Illinois governor and current Kankakee resident George Ryan
concluded when he suspended executions in 2000. Ryan, once an ardent death
penalty supporter, acted after growing doubts about the justice system and
after courts threw out the death sentences of 13 condemned men.
Shortly before leaving office in 2003, Ryan cleared death row, commuting the
sentences of 167 inmates to life in prison. In 2011, Gov. Pat Quinn took the
final step by abolishing the death penalty completely.
Many critics of those moves remain, and it's not hard to understand their
objections. If it is proven beyond a shadow of a doubt that someone has taken a
life or lives, then perhaps they should pay with their own.
But, if there is any doubt, and even if it further develops only after someone
is found guilty in a court of law, than how can you carry out an execution?
Ryan saw sense in that argument.
Will Oklahoma Gov. Mary Fallin come to the same realization before Sept. 16,
Glossip's scheduled date to die by lethal injection? It doesn't appear so, as
just last week, she issued a statement saying Glossip's execution will move
forward because she is convinced of his guilt and his conviction was upheld by
the U.S. Supreme Court.
But Supreme Court decision or not, it's difficult to discount the other factors
that might indicate Glossip is not guilty. The same can be said for many other
death penalty cases, and because of it, Oklahoma and the other 30 states that
still allow the death penalty should consider following the lead of Illinois.
(source: Editorial, Kankakee Daily Journal)
*********************
Why Oklahoma County Backed Off On Pursuing The Death Penalty
Oklahoma County was once among the top 2 % of counties nationwide that
accounted for 56 % of the people sitting on death row as of 2012, according to
the Death Penalty Information Center.
Between 1980 and 2001, Oklahoma County District Attorney Robert Macy won 54
death penalty convictions, just over 2 per year during the 21-year period. But
according data analyzed by the Marshall Project, Oklahoma County has only sent
3 people to death row in the past 6 years.
So what happened?
Former Oklahoma City criminal defense attorney Doug Parr says Oklahoma County
prosecutors are far more reluctant to issue death sentences after a 2001
investigation into police chemist Joyce Chilcrist after her scientific analysis
resulted in an innocent man spent 15 years in prison for a faulty rape
conviction:
The Federal Bureau of Investigation reviewed her cases in April 2001, finding
that she deliberately and repeatedly falsified DNA matches, withheld
exculpatory evidence, and failed to test samples sent to her laboratory. Macy
stepped down unexpectedly in June of 2001 but said the investigation wasn't
behind his early retirement. He cited a desire to spend more time with his
family. He died in 2011.
>From 1980 to 1993, Gilchrist provided evidence for thousands of the Oklahoma
County DA's criminal cases, including just over 1/2 of the convictions that
resulted in the death penalty. 11 of those people were executed before their
cases could be reviewed for errors.
In 2007, an Oklahoma County death row inmate was exonerated after Gilchrist's
testimony in that case was proven fraudulent. The state government and
innocence organizations continue to review other cases where convictions were
secured largely by her testimony.
(source: KGOU news)
More information about the DeathPenalty
mailing list